I may have dug my own grave tonight....

[xFingersx]

Basically just told my girlfriend she was a tasteless mongrel for liking Lord of the Rings over Star Wars.... I think I'm in deep shit lol

Lets see what everyone else thinks!

[Ash]

yeah I think your in deep shit

[xFingersx]

Since the post I've been arguing about this with 2 of her friends, which has ended with me posting this and ending the conversation..

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSJxvi767kQ

[ZephixLeer (Zephic)]

lol... I'm just going to guess you're in more trouble than you started in.

[xFingersx]

Eh.. If I wasn't the only one to support her when everyone else tells he she can't do something, then yea I probably would be dead meat right now... but she's pretty tolerant with my shenanigans...

[Ademaro]

Movies or game?

[Manic Velocity]

Star Wars and Lord of the Rings are the same story.  One is told in a galaxy far far away, the other in Middle Earth.

Congratulations, you're both nerds.  

[Da6onet]

Star Wars and Lord of the Rings are the same story.  One is told in a galaxy far far away, the other in Middle Earth.

Congratulations, you're both nerds.  

Nobody rips off anybody in these genres, they're both thought up by creative writers with original ideas...

Really Fingers, this is a moot argument, clearly Eragon (and by extension the Inheritance Cycle) trumps both franchises.

[xFingersx]

Nobody rips off anybody in these genres, they're both thought up by creative writers with original ideas...

Really Fingers, this is a moot argument, clearly Eragon (and by extension the Inheritance Cycle) trumps both franchises.

People watched that movie?

[Sared]

This thread makes me go


Damn fanboys...

Also...

Really Fingers, this is a moot argument, clearly Eragon (and by extension the Inheritance Cycle) trumps both franchises.

What in the hell man...

[Tbone]

Are bronies trickling into this guild?

[Da6onet]

What in the hell man...

Now I'm worried Sared, do you ask because you thought I was serious or because you knew I was being extremely sarcastic?

In either case, we need to have a talk.

[Sared]

Are bronies trickling into this guild?

Just this one! <3



In all seriousness though, Star Wars VS. LotR isn't even like comparing apples and oranges. More like comparing volcanos to naval destroyers. They're both great. Making the argument that one is better than another for whatever reason, particularly the justification of one or another's like or dislike of one or another is just silly.

[Sared]

What in the hell man...

Now I'm worried Sared, do you ask because you thought I was serious or because you knew I was being extremely sarcastic?

In either case, we need to have a talk.

We need to have a talk regardless because I don't see you on TS often enough to bullshit with you. <3

But for reference, I had in mind the movies. Enjoyable enough as I found the Eragon books, the movie was akin to eating my own earwax in comparison: maybe a good idea when I was two or three, but just awful as an adult.

[Erathaol]

I'm with Sared on all points.  Even the ponies.
When you're right, you're right.  And gentlemen, Sared is right.